Analyse
14 juillet 2019

Le DPA de la Société Générale pour violations de l’embargo cubain – manipulation du droit dans la guerre économique mondiale (En anglais)

Bastille Day Newsletter 2019 - Enforcement / Court Decisions

 

Three months after agreeing to settle for 1.3 billion dollars in the Libyan and LIBOR case 1, Société Générale signed another Deferred Prosecution Agreement (“DPA”) on November 18, 2018, with the US Attorney’s Office of the Southern District of New York (“SDNY”) for Cuba’s embargo violation 2.

Extraterritorial application of U.S. laws on embargo

As a matter of international law, an embargo should apply only to nationals of the concerned State or the nationals of the States imposing the measure, who must refrain from any commercial exchange with the State or entities subject to the measure says the leading French legal publication 3. The general sentiment in France is that in the case concerning Société Générale, the US have gone beyond that principle.

Sanction of the French bank justified by the use of the U.S. trade system

Put in place in 1962, the embargo on Cuba prohibits in particular most imports and exports between the U.S. and Cuba and has been strengthened several times 4. As a unilateral decision, it is supposed to be applicable only to US nationals.

By stating however that Société Générale “engaged in a deliberate practice of concealing the Cuban nexus of U.S. dollar payments that were made in connection with those facilities5 the agreement enshrines the US dollar as the tool of one of the US’s exports.

In the Société Générale case, the French bank has been accused of having, from 2004 to 2010, granted payment facilities to Cuban entities and hidden transactions, that should they have been revealed, would have been prohibited by the Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”).

Nearly 2,500 transactions occurred and are presumed to have used the U.S. trade system, amounting to a total of 13 billion dollars. Most of these transactions financed oil purchases or sales between a Dutch trading company and the Cuban state-owned company with a monopoly on crude oil production and refining.

The investigations revealed that a majority of the transactions were put an end to in 2007 in fear of the US authorities, which were at that time investigating violations of the Iranian embargo in various companies.

European companies and French banks in particular, have already faced investigations by US authorities and this is not the first time that such a fine is imposed. On June 30, 2014, BNP Paribas accepted to pay a 8.9 billion fine for violation of the U.S. embargoes on Cuba, Sudan and Iran 6 and in October 2015, Crédit Agricole, faced with similar charges, negotiated a 787 million dollar deal 7.

Economic and legal battle

More recently, on May 2, 2019, the US government reactivated Title III of the Helms-Burton Act, passed in 1996 but never implemented 8, paving the way for claims to be brought before US courts by US nationals against foreign persons and entities that have made profits by trading with nationalized Cuban companies.

This law enables proceedings to be brought against any foreign company (including European and Canadian) that manage business in Cuba – from hotel and tourist venues to rum distilleries and cigar factories 9.

At the announcement of this DPA and considering the application of unilateral measures against Cuba running contrary to international law, the EU has decided to react and threatens to bring the case before the World Trade Organization – marking a short-lived attempt at a recast of the global economic and legal landscape 10.

Contenu similaire

Analyse
19 mai 2025
CJIP Paprec : retour sur la répression pénale en cas de violation des règles d’attribution...
Le 10 février 2025, Paprec a signé une Convention judiciaire d’intérêt public (CJIP) afin de mettre fin aux poursuites à...
Événement
4 mars 2025
Paris Arbitration Week 2025 – Red flags et arbitrage : tendances et outils pour lutter contre la corruption
Navacelle organise aux côtés de Forensic Risk Alliance une conférence sur le thème de la conformité et l'arbitrage le 8...
Revue de presse
13 juin 2025
Revue de presse – Semaine du 9 juin 2025
Cette semaine, la revue de presse revient sur la mise en examen de Pascaline Bongo dans une affaire de corruption...
Actualité
13 juin 2025
Navacelle accueille Maxime Desplats en qualité d’associé
Navacelle est heureux d’annoncer l'arrivée et l’association de Maxime Desplats.
Actualité
12 juin 2025
Enquêtes internes : recommandation de 7 garde-fous juridiques pour plus d’efficacité
Le journal Les Echos publie un entretien croisé de Stéphane de Navacelle, Dominique Perben (Simon Associés) et Raphaël Gauvain (Stephenson...
Revue de presse
6 juin 2025
Revue de presse – Semaine du 2 juin 2025
Cette semaine, la revue de presse revient sur la coordination au niveau français des sanctions économiques décidées par l’Union européenne,...
Press review
6 juin 2025
Press review – Week of 2 June 2025
This week’s press review covers the coordination at the French national level of the economic sanctions decided by the European...
5 min
Revue de presse
30 mai 2025
Revue de presse – Semaine du 26 mai 2025
Cette semaine, la revue de presse revient sur la condamnation de la banque Edmond de Rothschild pour des faits de...
Événement
26 mai 2025
[Webinaire] Coopération renforcée contre la corruption : perspectives croisées Royaume-Uni, Suisse et France (en anglais)...
Les co-présidents du comité international de lutte contre la corruption de la section du droit international de l'American Bar Association...
Revue de presse
23 mai 2025
Revue de presse – Semaine du 19 mai 2025
Cette semaine, la revue de presse revient sur le positionnement d’Emmanuel Macron en faveur de la suppression de la Directive...
Revue de presse
16 mai 2025
Revue de presse – Semaine du 12 mai 2025
Cette semaine, la revue de presse revient sur la prise de position du chancelier allemand Friedrich Merz, qui appelle à...
Revue de presse
9 mai 2025
Revue de presse – Semaine du 5 mai 2025
Cette semaine, la revue de presse revient sur la démission de François Commeinhes de son poste de maire de Sète...
Revue de presse
2 mai 2025
Revue de presse – Semaine du 28 avril 2025
Cette semaine, la revue de presse revient sur les réquisitions prises à l’encontre de François Fillon dans l’affaire des emplois...