29 November 2021

The French Anti-corruption Agency’s practical guide to preventing conflicts of interests

On 18 November 2021, the French Anti-Corruption Agency (“AFA” or “the Agency”) published its definitive guidelines to preventing conflicts of interests. These guidelines aim at assisting private companies, industrial and commercial public establishments as well their representatives and compliance actors in identifying and addressing situations where conflicts of interests may arise. The guidelines are illustrated with examples of good practices observed by the Agency since its creation, in 2016.


Traditionally, the notion of “conflict of interests” is associated with the duty of probity and implies a contradiction between the personal interest of a public agent and the public interest that he or she must defend with independence, impartiality and objectivity.[1] Thus, the only legal definitions of conflict of interests are limited to the public sphere, such as those given by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)[2] or by the Law on transparency in public life, which are almost identical.[3] There was no formal definition of conflict of interest in the private sector.


I. A welcome definition of conflict of interests in the private sector

Situations of a conflict of interests within companies can lead to criminal consequences for both the legal entity and its executives. Although breach of probity offenses solely relate to the public sector, the complicity, the laundering and the concealment of such offenses may relate to conflict of interests within the private sector.[4] Additionally, the actus reus of the offence of breach of trust or misappropriation of corporate assets correlate to situations of conflict of interests.[5] Therefore, it is necessary to define what constitute a conflict of interests within the private sector to minimize the occurrence of criminal acts which can be significantly prejudicial to companies’ interests or image.

The Agency’s guidelines define conflicts of private interests as an “existing personal interest whose interference with the activities carried out within the organization is such as to influence or appears to influence the impartial, objective and independent execution of the activity on behalf of that entity”.[6] For there to be a situation of conflict of interests, the ascertained or apparent interference[7] of the personal interest over the corporate interest has to be sufficiently serious[8], as a personal interest is not in itself incompatible with the pursuit of the company’s interests.

The guidelines recommend that detection measures and preventive measures extend beyond situations of conflict of interests that are proven to exist and that such measures take into consideration those that are apparent and likely to damage the company’s image.[9]


II. Identifying situations of conflict of interests within the private sector through risk-mapping

 The Agency stresses that it is impossible to exhaustively detect all risks of conflict of interests as personal interests and corporate interests are numerous and diverse, and do not necessarily clash.[10] The company must identify individuals who, due to their positions within the company, can make decisions that may create obligations for the company, as well as individuals who can exercise significant influence over the company’s decisions, and whose personal interests, because of their nature or importance, may be detrimental to corporate interests.[11]

The AFA’s guidelines provide companies with multiple options in identifying risks of conflicts of interests. The Agency recommends the creation of a risk-mapping specific to conflict of interests, to identify such risks as part of the corruption risk-mapping pursuant to the Law “Sapin II” or even to include the detection process in the operational risk-mapping.[12]

The guidelines also recommend identifying sensitive positions, processes (purchases, sales, financial investments, HR management), and operations (prospecting, searching for new markets, operations with the public sector, external growth).[13] Additionally, the entity can hold a registry with all recurring situations of conflict of interests.[14]


III. Preventing and addressing conflicts of interests

The AFA points out that preventive measures and risk management measures pertaining to conflict of interests depend on the entity’s specific characteristics.[15] While the legislator may set some measures for specific fields of activity, it is commonly up to the entities to define and create their own conflict of interests policies, which may be contained in their anti-corruption policy, or in a dedicated procedure, or in any other document. Among these measures, a clear and precise policy on gifts and invitations is recommended to be able to keep track of goods received from third parties. Proper dissemination of the policies should follow.[16]

The Agency also states that it is possible to adapt employment contracts by inserting specific incompatibility clauses for certain positions or staff rotation procedures for positions identified as presenting risks of conflict of interests.[17] Similarly, the inclusion of contractual clauses creating an obligation for counterparties to declare and address potential conflicts of interests is recommended.[18]

The AFA further reminds entities to provide themselves with the means to detect potential or actual conflicts of interests. The implementation of a disclosure mechanism for such conflicts, together with training and awareness programs for employees and third-party contractors, are necessary to create an environment favorable to the detection of conflicts of interest.[19]

Finally, the guidelines provide several practical examples of remedial measures, such as adjusting the rights and obligations of an individual in a situation of conflict of interest (abstention from voting or participating at board of directors’ meetings)[20] or, in the most sensitive cases, putting an end to the situation of conflict by withdrawing oneself from a specific procedure or action.[21]

Related content

The discreet ramping up of environmental criminal law
5 December 2023
The discreet ramping up of environmental criminal law
Navacelle contributes to The Legal Industry Reviews' fourth edition about recent gradual application of environmental criminal law in France, with...
Colloque CNB médiation, compliance & vigilance
4 December 2023
Mediation vs compliance and vigilance duties roundtable
Stéphane de Navacelle took part in a Compliance, vigilance and mediation seminar on Novembre 30, 2023.
Formation EFB Navacelle - Session 3/10
23 November 2023
Defining the scope of the internal investigation: internal investigation sources and the investigation plan
EFB Degree - Internal investigation (3/10) What criteria need to be considered when deciding whether to carry out an internal...
ABA International Law Section
21 November 2023
Practical tips when dealing with corruption allegations in arbitration
Navacelle contributes to the American Bar Association International Arbitration Committee's Quarterly Newsletter (Q3 2023).
Press review
Press review Navacelle
17 November 2023
Press review – Week of 13 November 2023
This week, the press review looks back at the criminal proceedings against Bashar Al-Assad, leader of Syria, Gotabaya Rajapaksa, former...
Revue Justice Actualités #28
13 November 2023
Internal Investigation and Negotiated Justice (in French)
Can internal investigation be used to negotiate the investigation phase with prosecuting authorities? An article in French, by Guillaume Daieff, Stéphane...
Press review
20 October 2023
Press review – Week of 16 October 2023
This week, the press review looks back at the ECHR's decision on the conviction of Total and Vitol on charges...
Cambridge Forum 2023 - Roma
19 October 2023
Corruption in International arbitration: Are allegations of corruption a way out of International arbitration claims?
Stéphane de Navacelle contributed to the Global Forum on Corporate Criminal Liability for Cambridge Forums on corruption allegations versus arbitral...
EFB Degree - Internal investigation
19 October 2023
Internal investigation : Relationship between the lawyer-investigator and his client
EFB Degree - Internal investigation (2/10) How should attorney-client privilege be applied? What is the relationship with the client? What resources...
Press review
13 October 2023
Press review – Week of 9 October 2023
This week, the Navacelle press review looks back at the appeal conviction of the mayor of Sète, as well as...
Press review
Press review
6 October 2023
Press review – Week of 2 October 2023
This week, the Navacelle press review looks back at the search of the home of the former mayor of Saint-Jory...
Press review
Press review
29 September 2023
Press review – Week of 25 September 2023
This week, let's look back at the French Constitutional Council decision repealing an article of the French Criminal Procedure Code...