Analysis
14 July 2018

US guilty plea not valid ne bis in idem defense

Bastille Day Newsletter 2018 - Enforcement / Court Decisions

 

The Vitol Case refers to the Oil for Food matter which enabled Iraq (under embargo) to sell oil in exchange for humanitarian supplies matter from 1993 to 2003. In the aftermaths of the unveiling of this scandal, the oil trading company Vitol was prosecuted in the United States for bribery. Vitol entered into a guilty-plea in New-York State court for “grand larceny” under New-York criminal law.

The company was also prosecuted in France for the same facts and claimed that the guilty plea shielded the company from further prosecution pursuant to the French principle ne bis in idem. In March 14, 2018, the French Supreme Court (Cour de Cassation) ruled that the ne bis in idem principle could not be considered as a valid argument for companies trying to avoid criminal proceedings in France after signing a guilty plea in the US. In this decision, the French Supreme Court ascertained a broad appreciation of its territorial jurisdiction in order to enhance the prosecution of international corruption.

Related content

Publication
29 January 2026
Regulatory Implications of a Tainted Arbitration: Lessons from the TotalEnergies Case
Navacelle contributes to The Legal Industry Reviews' 11th edition, focusing on a rare example of the diversion of international arbitration,...
Analysis
5 December 2025
The forthcoming Directive 2023/0135 (COD) on combating corruption
In its latest issue of L'Observateur de Bruxelles, the Delegation of French Bars (Délégation des Barreaux de France) has published...
Analysis
5 November 2025
Modernization and strengthening of the French Financial Markets Authority’s powers
On September 16, 2025, a bill was introduced in the National Assembly to increase the powers of the AMF and...
Publication
13 September 2024
Cross-country insights: Addressing Corruption Allegations in Arbitration Disputes
This guide aims at providing a comprehensive understanding of how different countries handle allegations of corruption in the course of...
Analysis
9 April 2026
Gentlemen’s agreements, no-poach agreements and non-solicitation clauses: Presentation of Decision 25-D-03 of 11 June 2025...
In the context of increased scrutiny by competition authorities of practices affecting labor markets, a webinar organised by the Antitrust...
Press review
3 April 2026
Press Review – Week of 3 April 2026
This week’s press review covers the adoption by the European Parliament of the European Union’s first anti-corruption directive; the expansion...
Event
3 April 2026
Money Laundering in the age of cryptocurrency
Conference on anti-money laundering, presented to students in the Master 2 program in Economic Criminal Law and Compliance at Paris...
2 min
Analysis
31 March 2026
CACEIS Bank: Decision of the AMF Enforcement Committee of December 17, 2025
Following the H2O AM case, which resulted in a sanction against this management company in 2022, the AMF examined the...
Event
30 March 2026
[PAW 2026] The New Geopolitics of Arbitration
Conference on the New Geopolitics of Arbitration, held at the Paris Court of Economic Affairs, as part of the Paris...
2 min
Press review
27 March 2026
Press Review – Week of 27 March 2026
This week’s press review covers the publication by the Direction Générale de la Sécurité Intérieure (DGSI) of a report warning...
Press review
20 March 2026
Press Review – Week of 16 March 2026
This week’s press review covers the ruling of the French Cour de cassation on the so-called “fake bank advisor” fraud;...
Analysis
19 March 2026
Review of the CJIP agreement between HSBC and the PNF for aggravated tax fraud
In the context of the CumCum case, the French National Financial Prosecutor’s Office (PNF) and HSBC Bank plc concluded a...
Press review
13 March 2026
Press Review – Week of 9 March 2026
This week’s press review covers the conviction of the Rocher Group for failure to comply with its duty of vigilance,...
Event
11 March 2026
Paris Arbitration Week 2026 – The fight against bias and noise, which unconsciously cloud the...
Navacelle is hosting a panel on 26 March 2026, as part of the Paris Arbitration Week (PAW).
Event
10 March 2026
Paris Arbitration Week 2026 – Fraus omnia corrumpit… Really? Paris courts and the enforcement of...
Navacelle is hosting a panel regarding Corruption and Arbitration on 24 March 2026, as part of the Paris Arbitration Week (PAW).
Press review
6 March 2026
Press Review – Week of 2 March 2026
This week’s press review covers the conclusion of a Judicial Public Interest Agreement (CJIP) between the French National Financial Prosecutor’s...