Analysis
14 July 2018

Constitutional Council rules Executive prosecutorial oversight not in breach of separation of panel on the independence of the Public Prosecutor towards the executive

Bastille Day Newsletter 2018 - Enforcement / Court Decisions

 

Article 5 of the legal ordinance of December 22, 1958 provides that: “Prosecutors are placed under the direction and control of their hierarchy and under the authority of the Minister of Justice. At the hearing, their word is free.”

The independence of the Public Prosecutor is a long-standing debate and is subjected to harsh criticism. The judges union representatives indeed considered that the abovementioned provisions violate the principle of the separation of powers. On December 8, 2017 the Constitutional Council however ruled that article 5 of the legal ordinance of December 22, 1958 was in compliance with the Constitution. The Constitutional Council indeed considered that this article is compatible with the independence of the judiciary. Indeed, pursuant to article 30 of the French criminal procedure code the Minister of Justice provides general instructions with regard to the criminal policy to prosecutors but not for individual cases. The Constitutional Council thus considered that the provisions of the French constitution guarantee a well-balanced system between the independence of the judiciary and the government prerogatives and do not violate the principle of the separation of powers.

Related content

Publication
The discreet ramping up of environmental criminal law
5 December 2023
The discreet ramping up of environmental criminal law
Navacelle contributes to The Legal Industry Reviews' fourth edition about recent gradual application of environmental criminal law in France, with...
Analysis
UBS
17 November 2023
Saga UBS: second reassessment of the UBS’s historic financial penalty
On November 15, 2023, as part of the UBS saga that began on 20 February 2019, the judges on the...
Analysis
22 February 2024
New clarifications on the repression of tax fraud offences and tax fraud laundering by the...
On 13 December 2023, the Cour de cassation first ruled on the concept of non bis in idem, rejecting the...
Event
21 February 2024
Paris Arbitration Week 2024 – Ethics & Arbitration panel
Navacelle is hosting a panel regarding Ethics & Arbitration on 19 March 2024, during the Paris Arbitration Week (PAW).
Analysis
20 February 2024
A French dairy group suspected of tax fraud
Since 2018, Lactalis has been suspected of committing tax fraud and laundering the proceeds of such fraud via schemes involving...
Press review
16 February 2024
Press review – Week of 12 February 2024
This week’s press review looks back at the legacy of former French minister of Justice Robert Badinter who recently passed...
Press review
9 February 2024
Press review – Week of 5 February 2024
This week’s press review highlights the acquittal of former minister and mayor of Pau, François Bayrou, the accusation of a...
Press review
2 February 2024
Press review – Week of 29 January 2024
This week’s press review highlights the Transparency report on France's global position in the fight against corruption, Uber's fine in...
Analysis
30 January 2024
The European Public Prosecutor’s Office and TRACFIN signed a working arrangement for closer cooperation
In accordance with the principle of sincere cooperation between Member States and with the European Union's institutions, provided for in...
Press review
26 January 2024
Press review – Week of 22 January 2024
This week’s press review highlights Amazon’s 32 million euro fine by a French administrative authority for the monitoring of its...
Event
25 January 2024
Internal investigation and data collection
EFB Degree - Internal investigation Internal investigation and data collection: In many respects, data collection is crucial in conducting an internal...
Press review
19 January 2024
Press review – Week of 15 January 2024
This week, the press review covers the validation by the French Supreme Court of Lafarge’s indictment for complicity in crimes...
Publication
THE PRACTITIONER’S GUIDE TO GLOBAL INVESTIGATIONS - EDITION 8
15 January 2024
Practitioner’s Guide to Global Investigations (2024) – GIR
NAVACELLE co-author of the eighth edition of Global Investigations Review’s Practitioner’s Guide to Global Investigations.
Press review
Press review- Week of 8 January 2024
12 January 2024
Press review – Week of 8 January 2024
This week, the press review looks back at the conclusion of three Deferred Prosecution Agreements by Marseille’s Public Prosecutor’s office,...