Analysis
14 July 2018

Constitutional Council rules Executive prosecutorial oversight not in breach of separation of panel on the independence of the Public Prosecutor towards the executive

Bastille Day Newsletter 2018 - Enforcement / Court Decisions

 

Article 5 of the legal ordinance of December 22, 1958 provides that: “Prosecutors are placed under the direction and control of their hierarchy and under the authority of the Minister of Justice. At the hearing, their word is free.”

The independence of the Public Prosecutor is a long-standing debate and is subjected to harsh criticism. The judges union representatives indeed considered that the abovementioned provisions violate the principle of the separation of powers. On December 8, 2017 the Constitutional Council however ruled that article 5 of the legal ordinance of December 22, 1958 was in compliance with the Constitution. The Constitutional Council indeed considered that this article is compatible with the independence of the judiciary. Indeed, pursuant to article 30 of the French criminal procedure code the Minister of Justice provides general instructions with regard to the criminal policy to prosecutors but not for individual cases. The Constitutional Council thus considered that the provisions of the French constitution guarantee a well-balanced system between the independence of the judiciary and the government prerogatives and do not violate the principle of the separation of powers.

Related content

Analysis
21 May 2024
European judicial cooperation & transfer of criminal proceedings between Member States
On 5 April 2023, the European Commission adopted a proposal for a regulation on the transfer of criminal proceedings between...
Analysis
6 May 2024
Overview of the future European Anti-Money Laundering Authority
The new Authority for Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism will be based in Frankfurt and shall start...
Publication
27 February 2024
New sustainability reporting obligations in France: what’s new?
Navacelle contributes to The Legal Industry Reviews' fifth edition about the transposition of the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) in...
Press review
21 June 2024
Press review – Week of 17 June 2024
This week, the press review covers the admissibility of the actions against Total and EDF relating to breaches of the...
Event
19 June 2024
Compliance and forensic investigations: optimising how companies, lawyers and forensic professionals work together
Grant Thornton France invited Stéphane de Navacelle to take part in a panel with Jean-Marie Pivard (Publicis Groupe), Jennifer Fiddian-Green...
2 min
Event
19 June 2024
Discussion on harassment prevention and exposure
Invited by Colas Rail, Stéphane de Navacelle discussed with 100+ group top managers during their Management Committee 2024, on 19 June 2024.
2 min
Press review
14 June 2024
Press review – Week of 10 June 2024
This week, the press review covers three people being charged for fraud in the Hauts-de-Seine, the dismantling of an undeclared...
Event
13 June 2024
Future prospects for International Anti-Corruption Court
A panel held during the 20th Annual IBA Anti-Corruption Conference hosted at the OECD in Paris.
Press review
7 June 2024
Press review – Week of 3 June 2024
This week, the press review covers the trial of several Île-de-France’s elected officials including concealment of misappropriation of corporate assets...
Event
5 June 2024
Update on Sanctions Litigation, Arbitration, and Enforcement – with EU, French and Swiss perspectives
A panel held on 5 June 2024 in Berlin, during the C5's European Forum on Global Economic Sanctions.
Event
5 June 2024
Arbitration & the cohabitation of the ZLECAF and OHADA law
A webinar, in French, organised as part of the 3rd edition of the African International Arbitration Competition by he Arbitration...
Event
3 June 2024
Internal investigations by lawyers: how to approach labor & criminal law issues?
An animated debate on benefits brought by investigating lawyers on criminal or labor law investigations, i.e. independence, secret protection, confidentiality...
1 min
Press review
31 May 2024
Press review – Week of 27 May 2024
This week, the press review covers the conviction of a French senator for illegal taking of interest, the adoption of...
Analysis
29 May 2024
The challenge of regulating generative artificial intelligence
On February 14, the French National Assembly's Law Commission published a report on the challenges posed by generative artificial intelligence...
Press review
24 May 2024
Press review – Week of 20 May 2024
This week, the press review covers the fine imposed on bank company N26, the trial of EDF and its former...