Analysis
14 July 2018

AFA: a new French agency to fight corruption

Bastille Day Newsletter 2018 - What’s Hot

 

By enacting the Sapin II Act, France demonstrated its commitment to strengthen the national anticorruption framework and enforcement powers. One of the key features of this new piece of legislation was the creation of a French Anticorruption Agency (“AFA”). By granting it a wide range of prerogatives, the AFA has appeared as one of the essence of Sapin II.

French legislator arms itself with a new anticorruption instrument

In 2016, the French legislator enacted Sapin II, a legislative arsenal aiming at a providing efficient mechanisms to eradicate corruption. One of the milestone of this law has been the creation the AFA. Replacing the Central Corruption Prevention Department (“the SCPC”), the AFA has a broader scope to address more effectively corruption issues and comply with international requirements1.

Acting under the supervision of the Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Budget, AFA’s purpose is to assist authorities in the prevention and detection of corruption offenses, influence peddling or embezzlement2.

The strength of this new agency lies in its ability to conduct a 2-stage investigation in companies with over 500 employees and a benefit exceeding €100 million. During the first stage, companies have the obligation to forward all relevant documents to the agency3. The AFA will then investigate in the facilities of the company – interviewing any employees, clients or even subcontractors. The AFA will at the end issue a report which will be shared among the parties involved4. Based on its report and the company’s observations, the agency will decide whether it should issue a warning urging the company to put in place an effective compliance program. In case of unlawful conduct, AFA’s Commissions of Sanctions, composed of 6 magistrates, may issue a pecuniary fine against legal entities (up to €1 million) or private individuals (up to €200,000)5.

To carry out its mandate, the agency has also other prerogatives. Upon requests of the Prime Minister, the AFA must ensure that French companies which have been convicted in another country, comply with compliance requirements6. The AFA’s may also issue recommendations helping private and public entities to identify misconducts, influence peddling or embezzlement and improve their compliance programs7. Despite this wide scope, the AFA should not be seen as an sanctioning authority but a preventive authority as it puts forward the implementation of anticorruption programs.

Cooperation trumps prosecution

In an advisory opinion, the Conseil d’Etat, highest administrative authority in France, defined the role of this brand-new agency. Although the AFA participates in the fight against corruption, its mandate should not compete with other entities such as the National Financial Prosecutor Office (PNF).

The purpose of the AFA is to assist companies in the implementation of compliance programs and by doing so prevent unlawful conduct. In December 2017 for instance, the agency issued non-binding guidelines to help companies to address corruption issues and enact compliance programs. To draft these guidelines, the AFA relied on foreign legislations, and more precisely the Bribery Act 2010 and the Resource Guide to the U.S Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA guide)8.

In the light of the advisory opinion of the Conseil d’Etat, the AFA appears more as an auxiliary, assisting pre-existing anticorruption key players. Initially, the legislator provided the AFA with the ability to impose measures on the territorial collectivities. The Conseil d’Etat disagreed with such provision arguing that only the law may compel a public service to take measures9. Recommendations issued by the AFA are therefore only soft law as it does not have any binding effect10.

Despite its sanctioning power, the AFA increasingly appears as a cooperation instrument aiming at facilitating the implementation of compliance procedures than a repressive organ. The AFA may not prosecute unlawful obligations: it has an obligation to refer violations that are brought to its attention to the PNF11. It is in this aspect that the AFA mainly differs from the American Department of Justice and the UK Serious Fraud Offices. Indeed, the AFA has not issued a single sanction since its creation12. It has however started to monitor companies having entered into DPAs13.

* * *

In the past recent years, the French legislator was proactive in improving the anticorruption arsenal to comply with international standards, namely by establishing the AFA by Sapin II. The AFA thus transpires as a key stone in the fight against corruption. While the agency does not aim to compete with the PNF, DOJ and SFO, it is a vehicle permitting anticorruption practices to become second nature to economic actors.

Related content

Analysis
Proposition Loi Gauvain
20 October 2021
Analysis of the bill to reinforce the fight against corruption by Deputy Gauvain
Navacelle team has examined the “Bill to reinforce the fight against corruption” which has just been submitted by the Deputy Raphaël Gauvain at the National Assembly...
Julie Zorrilla
Partner Navacelle
Alexandre Coudreau
Student Sciences Po
Salomé Garnier
Associate Navacelle
News
19 October 2021
New decision in the jurisprudential saga in the field of arbitration and corruption
Navacelle team would like to inform you of a new decision in the jurisprudential saga in the field of arbitration and corruption.
Salomé Garnier
Associate Navacelle
Events
14 October 2021
The French criminal procedural law
Thomas Lapierre, associate at Navacelle presents the main elements of the French criminal procedural law for #LAWYEREX by European Lawyers Foundation.
Thomas Lapierre
Associate Navacelle
News
5 October 2021
Report of the Independent Commission on Sexual Abuse in the French Church
After two and a half years of work, the CIASE has submitted its report with the aim of understanding and analysing situations of sexual abuse of minors in the Catholic Fr...
Events
29 September 2021
Paris Legal Makers 2021
The first Paris Legal Makers conference dedicated to economic development through law will take place on 6 December 2021 at the Palais Brongniart.
News
27 September 2021
Update of French Financial Market Regulator (AMF) of its control charters (in French)
This update specifies the procedures for carrying out control missions, the principles of good conduct followed by those in charge of a control as well as the behavior ex...
News
27 September 2021
Update of French Financial Market Regulator (AMF) of its investigation charters (in French)
This update specifies the procedures for carrying out investigation missions, the principles of good conduct followed by those in charge of an investigation as well as th...
News
16 September 2021
The French DPA (“Convention judiciaire d’intérêt public”) on the way to simplification
On 4 August 2021, a new Decree was promulgated aiming to simplify formalities required for the conclusion of the CJIP between Public Prosecutors Office and the legal pers...
Julie Zorrilla
Partner Navacelle
Louis Beltaire
Trainee lawyer
Alexandre Desevedavy
Trainee lawyer
Salomé Garnier
Associate Navacelle
Publication
3 September 2021
The European Parliament Lays the Foundations of a Corporate Due Diligence and Corporate Accountability
Julie Zorrilla, Thomas Lapierre and Stéphane de Navacelle, highlight for the International Bar Association anticorrpution news, the adoption on 10 March 2021 by the Memb...
Stéphane de Navacelle
Managing partner Navacelle
Julie Zorrilla
Partner Navacelle
Thomas Lapierre
Associate Navacelle
Publication
20 August 2021
It’s not an “ego fight”: The do’s and don’ts of monitorships
Experts from around the world discuss what authorities, companies and monitors should do to ensure that a period of compliance oversight ends successfully. “the quality...
Julie Zorrilla
Partner Navacelle
Adam Dobrik
Journalist
Analysis
14 July 2021
The in-house attorney status in France: a bygone idea or an emerging one?
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Legislative, Regulatory & Policy Updates
Publication
14 July 2021
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021
Happy 2021 Bastille Day! Lawyers at Navacelle thought you might be interested in reviewing a selection we made of noticeable events which occurred in France in the fiel...
Stéphane de Navacelle
Managing partner Navacelle
Julie Zorrilla
Partner Navacelle
Clémentine Duverne
Partner Navacelle