Analysis
8 December 2020

NAVACELLE analyses recent overturn of the French Cour de cassation (25 November 2020)

NAVACELLE thought you might be interested by a succinct analysis of the recent overturn of the French Cour de cassation case law regarding the criminal liability of the acquiring company for acts committed by the acquired company prior to the merger by acquisition.

 

On 25 November 2020, the Criminal Chamber of the Cour de Cassation (French judicial Supreme Court) issued a major reversal of its case law, ruling that in the event of a merger by acquisition1, the criminal liability of the acquiring company could be incurred for acts committed by the acquired company before the merger.

In the present case, a company was summoned as a defendant in front of the Criminal Court for unintentional burning of property belonging to another, consequence of a breach of the legal duty of safety or caution required by law.

However, it appeared that the company had been acquired by merger by acquisition prior to the trial which therefore cannot proceed as the acquired company dissolved.

According to the long-standing case law of the Cour de cassation based on article 121-1 of the French Penal Code, an acquiring company cannot be prosecuted and convicted for offenses committed prior to the merger by the acquired company.

However, in its decision of 25 November 2020, the Criminal Chamber of the Cour de Cassation reversed its case law, ruling that the acquired company transfers its liabilities to the acquiring company in the event that the merger transaction falls under the scope of the European Directive 78/855/EC related to mergers of public limited liability companies.

This ruling is a result of the decision rendered by the European Court of Human Rights on 24 October 2019 ruling the existence of the economic and operational continuity between the acquired company and the acquiring company which excludes a distinction between their criminal liabilities.

However, the transfer remains limited. The acquiring company can only be condemned to a financial sanction such as a fine or confiscation.

Furthermore, the Criminal Chamber of the Cour de cassation establishes a specific regime for cases where the merger by acquisition is solely designed to avoid criminal liability of the acquired company. This regime applies to all companies, whether or not they fall under the scope of the European Directive.

In such cases, financial sanctions may be combined with additional sanctions, such as the dissolution of the company, debarment from public procurement, etc.

It therefore appears that it is henceforth essential to strengthen due diligence verifications regarding the situation of the acquired company, prior to any merger by acquisition, in order to establish the risk incurred by the acquiring company with certainty.

In the event of a criminal risk relating to the acquired company, a thorough analysis of the facts and the context of the merger by acquisition shall become good practice. Especially since the interpretation of this landmark decision and the concept of fraud by French courts remains uncertain.

 

  • Specific caution must be observed regarding the risk of criminal liability of public limited liability companies
  • Especially in cases where the merger by acquisition could be deemed designed to avoid criminal liability

Related content

News
27 September 2021
Update of French Financial Market Regulator (AMF) of its control charters (in French)
This update specifies the procedures for carrying out control missions, the principles of good conduct followed by those in charge of a control as well as the behavior ex...
News
27 September 2021
Update of French Financial Market Regulator (AMF) of its investigation charters (in French)
This update specifies the procedures for carrying out investigation missions, the principles of good conduct followed by those in charge of an investigation as well as th...
News
16 September 2021
The French DPA (“Convention judiciaire d’intérêt public”) on the way to simplification
On 4 August 2021, a new Decree was promulgated aiming to simplify formalities required for the conclusion of the CJIP between Public Prosecutors Office and the legal pers...
Julie Zorrilla
Partner Navacelle
Louis Beltaire
Trainee lawyer
Alexandre Desevedavy
Trainee lawyer
Salomé Garnier
Associate Navacelle
Publication
3 September 2021
The European Parliament Lays the Foundations of a Corporate Due Diligence and Corporate Accountability
Julie Zorrilla, Thomas Lapierre and Stéphane de Navacelle, highlight for the International Bar Association anticorrpution news, the adoption on 10 March 2021 by the Memb...
Stéphane de Navacelle
Managing partner Navacelle
Julie Zorrilla
Partner Navacelle
Thomas Lapierre
Associate Navacelle
Analysis
14 July 2021
What will be the impact of the transposition of the EU Directive on the protection of whistleblowers into French law?
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Legislative, Regulatory & Policy updates
Analysis
14 July 2021
The Bolloré case and the risks attached to the French Individual Guilty Pleas
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Enforcement & Court Decisions
Analysis
14 July 2021
The evaluation mission of the Sapin II law calls for a boost in France’s anti-corruption policy
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Legislative, Regulatory & Policy Updates
Analysis
14 July 2021
Criminal liability’s transfer to the acquiring company in the event of a merger by acquisition and consecutive due dil...
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Enforcement & Court Decisions
Analysis
14 July 2021
The PNF looks back on a very unusual 2020 year
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Legislative, Regulatory & Policy Updates
Analysis
14 July 2021
Compliance in the public sector: The Ministry of the Armed Forces issued its Code of prevention of breaches of probity
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Legislative, Regulatory & Policy Updates
Analysis
14 July 2021
The professional secrecy threatened by recent case law on seizure
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Enforcement & Court Decisions
Analysis
14 July 2021
Short overview of the French legal requirement for internal controls relating to the AML-CFT
Bastille Day Newsletter 2021 - Legislative, Regulatory & Policy Updates